Yesterday I did an analysis based on FiveThirtyEight.com's statistical predictions of the Presidential campaign. Although they called both Republican and especially Democratic primaries almost perfectly, I still think they're currently running a little bit too strong in Obama's favor.
If they're right, GREAT, but here's my own prediction, partly based on the polling, partly gut feeling.
First, I really believe that the racist vote will be considerably stronger than the polls show- the Bradley effect. It won't be that way nationwide, though- only in the most ignorant, backwards regions of the nation, which is to say Appalachia and the deep South (including my own Texas).
In Pennsylvania and Virginia the urban and suburban areas have grown too large for the Appalachian counties to overrule them; Obama will almost certainly win those states. North Carolina might break either way. Florida has more retired northern liberals, to be sure, but it also has more retired conservatives, and quite a number of racists, retired or not- I'm going to predict, in the face of current polls, that McCain carries it, along with the rest of the Confederacy except for Virginia.
I also include Ohio here; Cincinnati and the counties bordering Pennsyltucky are extremely unlikely to go for Obama, and there are enough people there to outweigh Cleveland and the Rust Belt counties to the north. McCain will hold Ohio.
Outside the above areas, I don't believe race will be an issue, and I'll go by the polls... with the proviso that the race will close a couple of points between now and Nov. 4.
The entire ACELA corridor and beyond, from Maine to DC and Virginia, will go for Obama, as will the Rust Belt except for the aforementioned Ohio and Indiana. He'll also pull in Iowa, which McCain lost on one of the few issues on which he's correct- corn ethanol subsidies. McCain opposes, Obama supports. Missouri, the ultimate border state, is too close to call, as North Carolina is.
McCain will take most of the interior West... but most of that area is uninhabited. Obama will take Colorado, New Mexico, and Nevada, and in all three cases the margin will be broad enough to leave us wondering why we ever thought any of them were swing states. North Dakota, somewhat surprisingly, is too close to call.
Finally, on the Pacific Coast, only Alaska goes to McCain; everything else goes to Obama.
To sum up: Virginia, New Mexico, Colorado and Nevada are the only states I expect to flip from red to blue. Nothing flips blue to red. North Dakota, Missouri and North Carolina are too close to call. Anything beyond that- Ohio, Florida, West Virginia, North Dakota, Indiana- will be gravy if they flip, but I don't much expect them to.
That's a 32 electoral vote swing away from the GOP to the Dems, with 30 electoral votes that could go either way.
And you know what? 32 electoral votes is enough. If only Virginia, New Mexico, Colorado and Nevada flip,
Obama wins 291-247. McCain has to hold Virginia
and Colorado
and either Nevada or New Mexico- and lose nothing else that Bush won in 2004- to win.
So... if Obama wins Virginia, color it over.
OK, given my prediction:
Obama wins Kerry 2004 + VA, CO, NV, NM - 291-247
... my pessimistic, worst-case scenario has Obama winning by margins pretty much the same as 2000 (271-266-1) and 2004 (286-251-1), except for a reversal of the parties. It would also be a Carter-Ford victory (297-240);
Let's add the other states that are currently considered possible flips, in order from most to least likely.
First, my "can't call" states- North Carolina, North Dakota, and Missouri are my order of probability:
Obama wins above + NC - 306-232 (1968 Nixon 301, Humphrey 191, Wallace 46; 1960 Kennedy 303, Nixon 219, Byrd 15)
... + ND - 309-229
... + MO - 320-218
And now for the others, ordered by poll margins:
... + FL - 347-191
... + OH - 367-171 (1992 Clinton 370, Bush 168, Perot 0)
... + IN - 378-160 (1996 Clinton 379, Dole 159, Perot 0)
... + WV - 383-155
(and these last three are, put bluntly, fantasyland)
... + MT - 386-152
... + GA - 401-137
... + MS - 407-131 (1988 Bush 426, Dukakis 111)
No one-sided landslides like Reagan '80 and '84, Nixon '72, or Johnson '64 this year, of course. McCain has at least eighteen states sewn up beyond all shaking.
(Have your own fun using CNN's electoral vote calculator:
http://www.cnn.com/ELECTION/2008/calculator/ )
(Historical results from
http://uselectionatlas.org/ )